For Sale
$499,900
10 & 11 Methodist Island N/A, Tay, ON
Port McNicoll, Tay
4 bd1 ba900 sqftDetached
Details
~$2,598/mo to carry, est.
$555/sqft
Listed by Keller Williams Home Group Realty.
Port McNicoll, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
From PropTx
$499,000
As listed by the seller and their brokerage. It is a request, not a valuation, and nothing tests it until an offer arrives.
From MyNest360
The tools we build on top of the listing, each figure sourced and none of it PropTx data: what the house really costs to hold, what it costs to borrow against, and the inspection to book before your conditions come off.
From PropTx
The price, facts, description and history exactly as the feed states them. Nothing in this section is our own estimate.
Counts and measurements as the listing states them, not verified by us. Source: PropTx
The listing does not say whether there is a second dwelling unit here. Other records in this set state it either way, so this is a silence rather than a no.
What comes from PropTx, and what is ours
The price, address, room and size figures, description and days on site are sourced from PropTx and can lag the live listing. The map placement and the cost, offer, insurance and rental tools below are our own work, not PropTx data. Anything we have modelled rather than sourced carries an Est. tag.
1 event between Sep 10, 2026 and Sep 10, 2026.
Asking price moved from $499,000 on Sep 10, 2026 to $499,000 on Sep 10, 2026, a change of $0.
RARE FIND! Beautifully maintained home nestled in a quiet, sought-after neighbourhood in Paradise Point. Just a short walk to the beach, this spacious property offers the perfect blend of modern, comfort, privacy and relaxed lakeside living. Step inside to a bright and inviting main floor featuring vaulted ceilings, large windows and an abundance of natural light. The generous open living space is complemented by pot lights and engineered hardwood flooring throughout. The spacious dining area offers a walkout to the wrap-around verandah. The well-appointed kitchen features granite countertops, a raised breakfast bar, wall oven and microwave, gas cooktop and beautiful travertine tile flooring. A convenient walkout leads directly to the backyard deck, making outdoor dining and entertaining effortless. The home offers two extra-large bedrooms, each with multiple windows providing plenty of natural light and comfortable living space. The primary bedrooms boasts a large walk-in closet for added convenience. Two bathrooms include a spacious main bath with double vanity and a separate shower featuring a multi-function shower system. Outside, the fully fenced backyard is a private retreat surrounded by lush mature trees and plenty of green space. Enjoy the expansive deck, firepit and garden shed, with ample room for entertaining, relaxing and enjoying the outdoors. A large driveway provides plenty of parking, while the wrap-around verandah adds to the home's welcoming curb appeal. Ideally located within walking distance to the beach and Patterson Park, this well-cared-for, move-in ready home is situated in a peaceful neighbourhood while still being close to the amenities and recreation Port McNicoll has to offer. A wonderful opportunity to enjoy spacious, comfortable living in a beautiful community.*Owned water heater. R50 insulation used at construction. Insulated crawl space with sump pump. Drilled well. UV filtration & reverse osmosis system*
Written by the listing brokerage to sell the house. Nothing in it is verified, so take its claims about condition to an inspection, not from it.
The pills are copied from the listing and sorted for reading, with nothing added to them, and a group the listing did not fill in is absent rather than empty. Where a group is written as sentences instead, those are ours: what the listing named, and what it means.
On the record, and not one of the groups above.
1 years, from $3,859 in 2026 to $3,859 in 2026.
Neighbourhood market statistics is not shown here
Not shown: our current listing agreement does not licence this figure for display.
Medians, sale-to-list ratios and absorption are computed from sold prices, and they are licensed to registered users only. There is no approximate version of a median that would be honest to show in their place.
Every home of this type in Tay that has sold in the last 3 years.
Contact details for the listing agent are not shown: our current listing agreement licences them to registered users only.
Sourced from: PropTx. Last updated Sep 10, 2026.
From MyNest360
None of this is PropTx data. Each figure is our own and carries its source: the true cost to own, the mortgage studio, the inspection plan, and the rest.
Two figures stand against this house for two different purposes, the asking price and the assessment, so they do not agree and were never meant to. The gap is worked out here rather than left for you to hold in your head.
Nothing of this kind on the record, and nothing here fills it in from an average of other houses.
The figure property tax is apportioned from, valued as of a date that is not today. It is not a market value and no lender treats it as one.
None of these is an appraisal. Your lender orders one of those once an offer is accepted, and it is the figure that decides how much they will actually lend.
At 20% down and 4.28% fixed, the all-in monthly cost works out to $2,685. Every line, the pool and the well included, plus the first-year total, is on the full breakdown.
At 20% or more there is no CMHC premium.
20% down · 4.28% indicative 5-yr fixed · The number of years the whole balance is paid off over. A longer amortization lowers the monthly payment and raises the total interest.. $3,859 for 2026, from the tax figure stated on the listing, divided by twelve. That is what the current owner pays, as the listing states it. That twelfth is the annual amount levelled across the year and not a payment you will make on any date. How a municipality actually collects it is set out in documents nobody here has read.; heat and utilities estimated. Figures illustrative.
Compare lenders and private optionsIt asks one question first: whether someone is already acting for you. That answer changes who books the visit and who is on your side inside the house.
Connect with Tara
Tara McCarthy
Broker, VP Ultra Luxury Division
Every question about this home reaches a licensed broker, not a form.
Scott McGillivray’s Trusted Network
Trades and more, once the keys are yours
Check out Scott’s preferred network to find licensed, insured trades and more.
Explore the networkSourced from MyNest360
Figures such as 4.79% sample rates and estimates are illustrative only. Verify all details with a licensed professional before making an offer.
Listed by Keller Williams Home Group Realty.
Listed by Team Hawke Realty.
Listed by SUTTON GROUP INCENTIVE REALTY INC..
Listed by Royal LePage In Touch Realty.
Listed by Royal LePage In Touch Realty.
Listed by Forest Hill Real Estate Inc..