For Sale
Port McNicoll, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
From PropTx
$425,000
As listed by the seller and their brokerage. It is a request, not a valuation, and nothing tests it until an offer arrives.
From MyNest360
The tools we build on top of the listing, each figure sourced and none of it PropTx data: what the house really costs to hold, what it costs to borrow against, and the inspection to book before your conditions come off.
From PropTx
The price, facts, description and history exactly as the feed states them. Nothing in this section is our own estimate.
The listing does not state a bedroom count.
The listing does not state a bathroom count.
Counts and measurements as the listing states them, not verified by us. Source: PropTx
What comes from PropTx, and what is ours
The price, address, room and size figures, description and days on site are sourced from PropTx and can lag the live listing. The map placement and the cost, offer, insurance and rental tools below are our own work, not PropTx data. Anything we have modelled rather than sourced carries an Est. tag.
This listing's price and status history is available to members
Sign in to see: this figure is available to registered members with a verified account.
Prior asking prices, terminations and relists are licensed to registered members only. Nothing here should be read as evidence that the current price is the only price this house has been offered at: it is a limit on who we may show this to, not a finding about the listing.
Sign in or create an account with a verified email and accept the terms of use to see the full history.
Sacred Heart Parish - A Unique Opportunity in the Heart of Port McNicoll. Discover the possibilities with this well-maintained landmark property situated on an 85' x 118' lot in the community of Port McNicoll. Offering approximately 3250sq. ft. of finished space on the top level, this former church presents a rare opportunity for investors, community organizations, institutions, or those seeking a distinctive redevelopment project. Currently zoned Institutional, the property permits a variety of uses including places of worship, community centres, clinics, schools, day nurseries, retirement facilities, nursing homes, and other institutional uses (buyers to complete their own due diligence regarding permitted uses and future development potential). The building has been thoughtfully maintained over the years with major updates including a steel roof, soffit, fascia, eavestroughs, raised edge on the flat roof, snow guards, and gable siding completed in 2015. Additional improvements include a new 50-gallon hot water tank and a 100,000 BTU furnace installed in 2020.Inside, you'll find soaring ceilings, beautiful stained-glass windows, and the character and craftsmanship often found in historic church buildings..Whether you're looking to continue its current use, establish a community-focused facility, or explore other permitted institutional opportunities, this property offers exceptional potential in a growing Georgian Bay community. A rare chance to own a piece of local history while bringing your vision to life. Call today for your personal tour - Land located at 401 McNicoll Street across the road also for sale
Written by the listing brokerage to sell the house. Nothing in it is verified, so take its claims about condition to an inspection, not from it.
Neighbourhood market statistics is available to members
Sign in to see: this figure is available to registered members with a verified account.
Medians, sale-to-list ratios and absorption are computed from sold prices, and they are licensed to registered users only. There is no approximate version of a median that would be honest to show in their place.
Every home of this type in Tay that has sold in the last 3 years.
Contact details for the listing agent are not shown: our current listing agreement licences them to registered users only.
Sourced from: PropTx. Last updated Jun 4, 2026.
The information provided herein must only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale or lease of real estate and may not be used for any commercial purpose or any other purpose. Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board or PropTx.
From MyNest360
None of this is PropTx data. Each figure is our own and carries its source: the true cost to own, the mortgage studio, the inspection plan, and the rest.
At 20% or more there is no CMHC premium.
20% down · 4.59% indicative 5-yr fixed · The number of years the whole balance is paid off over. A longer amortization lowers the monthly payment and raises the total interest.. No assessment on the record and no rate on file for this municipality, so the tax line is 0.70% of the price a year. That is a GTA figure, and the GTA holds the lowest residential rates in Ontario, so on an address outside it this line is likely to be low rather than imprecise, by a third or more.; heat and utilities estimated. Figures illustrative.
Compare lenders and private optionsIt asks one question first: whether someone is already acting for you. That answer changes who books the visit and who is on your side inside the house.
Connect with Tara
Tara McCarthy
Broker, VP Ultra Luxury Division
Every question about this home reaches a licensed broker, not a form.
Scott McGillivray’s Trusted Network
Trades and more, once the keys are yours
Check out Scott’s preferred network to find licensed, insured trades and more.
Explore the networkSourced from MyNest360
Figures such as 4.79% sample rates and estimates are illustrative only. Verify all details with a licensed professional before making an offer.
The listing does not say whether there is a second dwelling unit here. Other records in this set state it either way, so this is a silence rather than a no.
Listed by RIGHT AT HOME REALTY.
Listed by CENTURY 21 ATRIA REALTY INC..
Listed by Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd..
Listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd.
Two figures stand against this house for two different purposes, the asking price and the assessment, so they do not agree and were never meant to. The gap is worked out here rather than left for you to hold in your head.
Nothing of this kind on the record, and nothing here fills it in from an average of other houses.
The figure property tax is apportioned from, valued as of a date that is not today. It is not a market value and no lender treats it as one.
None of these is an appraisal. Your lender orders one of those once an offer is accepted, and it is the figure that decides how much they will actually lend.
Listed by RIGHT AT HOME REALTY.
At 20% down and 4.59% fixed, the all-in monthly cost works out to $2,733. Every line, the pool and the well included, plus the first-year total, is on the full breakdown.
Listed by CENTURY 21 ATRIA REALTY INC..
Listed by Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd..
Listed by Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd..
Listed by Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd..
Listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd.